true crime podcast

26- Holey Sh!t

26- Holey Sh!t

When the mother of a teenage criminal manipulates him and his young wife into forming a suicide pact, a horrific chain of events follows. Did Kathleen Holey get away with murder? And what became of the couple's innocent children?

16- Asylum

16- Asylum

The Michigan Asylum for Insane Criminals in Ionia was part of Mid-Michigan’s landscape for over 90 years. During its reign, the institution treated thousands of patient. But its walls weren’t the strongest, and sometimes inmates disappeared. The results were often disastrous. In this episode, Dani and Jenn talk about two tragic cases in which escaped mental patients preyed on Mid-Michigan’s most vulnerable residents.

07- My Favorite Podcast

07- My Favorite Podcast

Just ahead of their team-building trip to see My Favorite Murder live, Jenn and Dani pay homage to the queens of true crime by discussing the best (or worst?) Michigan cases covered by MFM.

06- Shooting Marbles

06- Shooting Marbles

A love triangle turned Old West style shootout in 1800s Ingham County. Dani and Jenn deconstruct the crime and discuss the Marble legacy with Carol Koenig, the current owner of the estate where the murders took place.

03 - Family Man

03 - Family Man

What could possibly be worse than being murdered by a member of your own family, someone you loved and trusted? How about being buried beside them for all eternity? Jenn and Dani vent about this horrific practice, and how shockingly common it is.

01 - Rivalry

01 - Rivalry

Located less than 100 miles apart, the rivalry between Michigan State University and the University of Michigan has been going strong for decades. Football, basketball, hockey…serial killers? In their super-sized first episode, Jenn and Dani pit evil against evil in a battle for the title of MVP (Most Vile Psycho), with input from a very special guest- author and star of the History Channel's American Ripper Jeff Mudgett, a direct descendant of America's first serial killer.